In this insightful webinar, we sat down with retail leaders from Steve Madden (Dolce Vita, Betsey Johnson), and J.Crew (J.Crew Factory, Madewell) to discuss details on preparing for peak holiday season, leveraging returns to drive loyalty (and boost loyalty programs), and critical considerations for returns like metrics and profitability.

Customer Experience

How can retailers prepare for the influx of returns during the holiday season and ensure a smooth customer experience?

Several strategies can be implemented to prepare for the holiday return rush:

Extend return windows: Offering extended return windows, such as through the end of January for purchases made in November and December, provides customers with ample time to make returns, particularly for gifts.
Convenient return options: Providing various return options enhances convenience and improves the customer experience. Options like instant refunds, third-party dropoffs, at-home pickups, and partnerships with courier services for return pick-ups can be implemented.
Focus on exchanges: Streamlining the exchange process, especially for first-time shoppers who may be uncertain about sizing, can encourage customers to try different products and potentially make a purchase rather than simply returning the item.

How can returns data be used to improve the customer experience and drive loyalty?

Returns data provides valuable insights into customer preferences and product performance. By analyzing this data, retailers can:

Identify and address issues: Monitoring returns data in real-time allows retailers to promptly identify problematic products or recurring issues. For instance, if a specific product has a high return rate due to sizing inconsistencies, the retailer can take corrective measures, such as updating size charts or providing more detailed fit information on the product page.
Personalize recommendations and marketing: Utilizing data on customer returns and purchase history enables retailers to personalize product recommendations and marketing campaigns. By highlighting products with low return rates and high customer engagement, retailers can cater to individual preferences and increase the likelihood of repeat purchases.
Proactive customer service: Returns data can be used to identify customers who have had negative return experiences. Retailers can proactively reach out to these customers, offer apologies, provide solutions, and potentially offer incentives to encourage future purchases, thereby fostering customer loyalty.

“If it’s a first-time shopper… [their experience] could make or break them shopping with you again. So you don’t want to make things too difficult. Again, if you can get that customer back after the BSM rush, you’ve really locked them in and you only have a chance of that happening if you leave them with a great first impression.” – Colleen Waters (Steve Madden)

Returns Fraud and Abuse

What are some common types of return fraud and abuse, and how can retailers identify them?

Common types of return fraud and abuse include:

Wardrobing: Customers purchase items with the intent of wearing/using them for a specific event and then returning them.
Bracketing: Customers purchase multiple sizes or variations of the same item, intending to keep only one and return the rest.
Returning items with missing parts or sending back different items.

Retailers can identify these behaviors through:

Data analysis: Analyzing returns data for patterns, such as frequent returns from the same customer or a high volume of returns for specific products, can help identify potential abuse.
Technology solutions: Implementing technology solutions that track customer returns behavior, flag suspicious activity, and integrate with fraud prevention systems can help mitigate risk.
Partnering with specialized vendors: Collaborating with vendors specializing in return fraud detection and prevention can provide expertise and tools to combat fraudulent activities.

How can retailers effectively address return fraud and abuse while maintaining a positive customer experience?

Addressing fraud and abuse requires a balanced approach to protect the business without alienating genuine customers. Strategies include:

Clear return policies: Establishing transparent and well-defined return policies outlining acceptable and unacceptable return conditions, timeframes, and associated fees helps manage customer expectations.
Data-driven decision-making: Utilizing returns data to identify patterns of abuse allows retailers to implement targeted interventions, such as implementing stricter return policies for specific customer segments or product categories.
Customer communication: Communicating with customers who exhibit suspicious return behavior can help deter future abuse. This could involve sending reminders about return policies, requesting additional information, or offering alternative solutions, such as exchanges or store credit.
Technology-assisted monitoring: Implementing technology solutions to track customer returns behavior and flag suspicious activity enables retailers to identify and address potential fraud more effectively.

Return Policies

How have return policies evolved in recent years to address changing customer behavior and rising return rates?

Recent trends in return policies include:

Introduction of return fees: Many retailers have started charging for returns, either through shipping fees or restocking fees, to offset the increasing costs associated with handling returns.
Personalization of return policies: Some retailers are exploring personalized return policies based on customer behavior, offering more lenient policies to loyal and profitable customers while implementing stricter policies for those who exhibit patterns of abuse.
Shorter return windows: Some retailers have shortened return windows for certain product categories, particularly seasonal items or those prone to wardrobing, to mitigate losses and ensure that returned items can be resold.

What data points should retailers consider when evaluating and adjusting their return policies?

Key data points for evaluating return policies include:

Return rate: The overall percentage of items returned provides a general overview of return activity.
Return reasons: Understanding the reasons behind returns, such as sizing issues, quality concerns, or simply a change of mind, can guide adjustments to product descriptions, sizing charts, or customer service processes.
Return time: Analyzing the timeframe within which customers typically return items helps determine appropriate return windows and minimize the risk of receiving out-of-season or damaged goods.
Customer segmentation: Analyzing return behavior by customer segments allows retailers to tailor return policies based on customer lifetime value and loyalty, rewarding valuable customers with more flexible policies.

“ Most of the time retail is most focused on gross sales. Now [retailers are asking] what is the impact of returns on the net margin on the net sales. It’s about profitability at the end of the day.” – Amanda Yan (J.Crew)

Future of Returns

Future trends in customer expectations for returns include:

Increased demand for speed and convenience: Customers are likely to expect faster processing times for returns and more convenient return options, such as instant refunds, seamless online return portals, and expanded drop-off locations.
Emphasis on sustainability: As environmental awareness grows, customers may favor retailers with sustainable return practices, such as minimizing packaging waste, offering returnless refunds for low-value items, and partnering with eco-conscious logistics providers.
Personalized return experiences: Tailoring return experiences based on individual customer behavior and preferences will become more prevalent, rewarding loyal customers with flexible return options and addressing concerns proactively.

What key metrics should retailers track to measure the effectiveness of their post-holiday return strategy?

Essential metrics for evaluating post-holiday return strategy effectiveness include:

Customer return rate: This metric measures the percentage of customers who make returns, indicating the overall customer satisfaction with the return process.
Repurchase rate: Tracking the percentage of customers who make subsequent purchases after returning an item reflects customer loyalty and the effectiveness of the return experience in retaining customers.
Financial impact: Analyzing the financial implications of returns, including the impact on net sales, profit margins, and operational costs, helps assess the overall efficiency of the return process and identify areas for improvement.
Operational efficiency: Monitoring metrics such as return processing time, the percentage of items successfully resold, and the cost per return provides insights into the efficiency of the reverse logistics operations.
Watch the Webinar On Demand

See all articles